Baskets
Basket Reed and Caning Reed      
Batting                                     Some crib quilt size pieces, some scraps for crafts or fill
Beads      
Books                                      Quilting, Arts and Crafts, or kids books that are coming apart for decoupage 
Book Covers                              From kids and adult hardcover books.
Boxes                                       Small, from cards, or jewelry, or gifts    
Buttons
Candles                                    New, Used 
Candle Making Supplies               New wicks, dye, scent, shaved soy wax
Cards                                      New greeting cards, also used covers for crafts.     
Card Catalogue Cards      
Cardboard Tubes                       Thick. Short and wide. Long and skinny. 
Clock Hands                              Dozens! New!      
Contact Paper 
Corks                                       On occasion.     
Crepe Paper Rolls
Crochet Thread and Hooks
Crochet Thread      
Dried Flowers      
Elastic 
Embroidery Thread
Envelopes 
Ephemera     
Fabric                                      Generally a $1/yard. Or bag of scraps for $1
Fabric Sample Books       
Fat Quarters and precut quilt squares
Feathers                                  Go as fast as they come
Felt      
Felted Wool Scraps    
Fishing lures                              Plain    
Foamboard 
Formica Samples
Frame samples Corners
Game pieces/cards                     Incomplete
Gift Bags     
Glitter                                      Goes as fast as it comes. 
Holiday items   
Jewelry                                      New, Used, Broken, plus Single Earrings   
Jewelry making supplies 
Key Rings                                  With, without chain     
Kits                                          Cross Stitch, Embroidery, Crewel, Latchook.  New and Used.   
Knitting Needles      
Lace      
Latch Hook Yarn and Hooks      
Lids                                          Clean, all pink, all blue. Also assorted colors.    
Linoleum Samples      
Magazines                                  Fine Art, Craft, CrossStitch, Ones for collage for preschools (i.e. lots of pictures)
Maps
Marbles                                      On occasion.
Mat Board                                   Remnants, as well as corner samples     
Metal Tongs                                Mini      
Miniatures      
Modeling Clay                              New and used. Occasionally.
Office supplies                             Partial boxes or partially used 
Paint                                          Craft paint, fabric paint, glass paint, finger paint on occasion.    
Paintbrushes    
Paper pads 
Party decorations                          Used, partial packs.  
Patterns    
Pens and Pencils                            New and used.    
Pictures Frames                             Big, small. With glass, without glass.    
Pinecones
Plastic Eggs
Plastic disks                                  Many, 2 inches across, 1/4 inch thick, or so    
Plastic tubing                                Colorful     
Poly-Fil                                        Occasionally 
PomPoms 
Posters                                        Laminated, for teachers.  
Puzzles                                        Incomplete (Generally)
Records                                       Use as is, or make a bowl, or use the cover as wall art   
Ribbon                                         New and used rolls, as well as scrap ends.
Scrapbooking Supplies                    Paper, Stickers, Embellishments    
Sequins                                       On occasion    
Sewing Notions 
Sculpy                                        On occasion
Shells                                         On occasion 
Shoelaces                                   On occasion    
Silk Flowers      
Slides                                         Swarthmore Art History Collection (There's 21,000--come get 'em!)
Snaps 
Spools                                        Wooden, sometimes Plastic 
Stationary                                   Partial packs
Stencils   
Stickers                                       Many new, and also used. Plus many 80s name stickers!    
Sticky backed paper                      On occasion    
Thread      
Tile                                             Varies in size and amount    
Tins                                            Decorative 
Tissue Paper                                 New—for gifts, or used—for crafts  
Vintage items 
Wallpaper                                     Samples, Rolls 
Wax                                            Shaved, new. Beeswax, on occasion.    
Wooden Cut-Outs      
Wooden pieces      
Wooden Plaque Boards
Wreathes                                    Grapevine, straw base     
Yarn                                           Full skeins, part skeins, bags of misc. lengths    
Zippers 

and many more usual, and unusual items.